6 train at 77th St: is the front car actually emptier at rush hour, or am I fooling myself?
#1

I’m on the downtown 6 at 77th St most mornings around 8:15, and I’ve developed this habit of walking to the front of the platform—past the stairs, almost to the tunnel—because I’m convinced the first car is emptier. Last Wednesday I was running late, got on the middle car, and actually found a seat. Now I’m questioning everything.

Is the front car actually less crowded at 77th, or am I just trading a longer walk for the same crush? I’ve heard theories: that the front car is emptier because most people enter from the 77th St stairs and don’t walk forward; that it’s worse because it lines up with the wrong exit at 59th; that it’s all just luck. I board at 77th and get off at 59th, so I’m only on for a few stops. Does car choice actually matter on that stretch?

I’m also curious about the exit at 59th. I feel like I’m always behind a wall of people getting off, and I can’t tell if that’s because I’m in the wrong car or because everyone has the same idea. If you ride the 6 regularly, what’s your actual strategy? Do you walk to a specific car, or just take whatever’s there? I’m not talking about avoiding the last car at night—this is purely a rush-hour space question.

#2

Ha, this is basically the subway version of that thread “Is the classic Citi Bike just a rolling speed bump on the Manhattan Bridge now?” (Is the classic Citi Bike just a rolling speed bump on the Manhattan Bridge now?)—everyone’s got a theory and half of it is vibes.

I ride the 6 from 86th, not 77th, but my take: front car is usually better because the stairs at 86th dump everyone into the middle. At 77th I think it’s similar—people don’t walk. But it’s not a magic trick. By the time the train hits 77th it’s already full from 86th and 96th, so you’re really just choosing where to stand, not whether you’ll get a seat. I’d try the second car, not the first—first car sometimes has a little clump of people for no reason. Pam, have you tried timing it so you’re at the front when the board says the train is still a couple minutes out? That’s the only time the walk pays off for me.

#3

I’m team “just take the car that stops in front of you”—the 6 at 77th is a zoo either way. But I will say the front car on the downtown platform at 77th is usually where the people who know the 59th St exit go, so it can feel emptier at first and then everyone piles in at 68th or whatever.

My real hack: walk to the car that lines up with the 77th St stair but one car uptown. Everyone stops at the first door they see, so you get a tiny head start. It’s not scientific. Pam, report back if the second car ever actually gets you a seat.

#4

Pete, your point about the train already being full from 86th and 96th is the key. I tried the second car this morning—slightly better standing room, but no seats. Sunsetspark, the “one car uptown from the stair” trick works because people are lazy, but at 77th the platform is narrow enough that you can get stuck behind the crowd walking forward. I’ve done it and watched the doors close while I was still behind someone with a rolling suitcase.

My updated take: on the 6 at 77th, car choice is a marginal gain, not a hack. If you’re getting off at 59th and your exit is closer to the middle, the front car costs you a walk anyway. Better to optimize for where you stand on the platform, not which car. That said, I’ll keep testing because apparently I have no other hobbies.