Brooklyn bar with a real jukebox—not a TouchTunes tablet—does it still exist?
#1

Okay, I know this sounds like a unicorn hunt, but I refuse to believe every bar in Brooklyn has surrendered to the TouchTunes tablet. I want a real jukebox—the kind with physical CDs or, dream scenario, 45s—where the music feels like the room picked it, not an algorithm. Bonus points if the bartender doesn’t sigh when you feed it. I’m thinking North Brooklyn/Red Hook-ish, but I’ll travel for the right machine. Where do you actually go? Have you tried a spot recently where the jukebox was the whole reason to stay? I need specifics—neighborhood, vibe, whether it’s a CD carousel or just a glorified Spotify screen with a coin slot.

#2

Honestly, most spots swapped to TouchTunes years ago because it’s easier and probably cheaper for them. But there’s a bar on Franklin Ave—east side, between Atlantic and Fulton-ish—that still has a CD jukebox in the back. It’s not a museum piece, but it plays. Vibe is divey, no frills, and the jukebox gets loud after 10. I wouldn’t plan a whole night around it, but it fits what you’re asking. The one on Wyckoff is also decent if you’re already out that way. Just don’t expect a curated vinyl situation.

#3

Wait, bars still have actual CDs? I’m pretty new to Brooklyn and honestly I just assumed every jukebox was an app now. The places I’ve been to all had the tablet thing and someone kept queuing the same three songs. How do you tell before you walk in? Do you just peek at the corner? I’d feel weird doing a full lap of the bar just to check the music setup.

#4

I’d second the Franklin Ave one, but go early. After 11 it turns into a scene and the jukebox gets drowned out. grand_st_g is right that most places are tablets now—it’s sad. The bar on Van Brunt in Red Hook also has a real jukebox, or at least it did last time I was there. That’s more of a commitment to get to, but the room is worth it. not_from_here, you can usually spot the machine near the back wall or by the bathroom hall.

#5

Yes! The CD carousel is the detail I care about—there’s something about watching someone flip through a hundred discs and then commit to one terrible song that a tablet just can’t replicate. Have you tried the one near the Morgan L? I’ve heard it’s got a real jukebox but I haven’t made it over yet. I’m also weirdly obsessed with whether places maintain them—like, is there a guy who services the mechanism, or does it just slowly die? A dead jukebox is worse than no jukebox.

#6

The Morgan L one is fine but the beer list is whatever—stick to a cheap draft and you’ll be happy. The jukebox is real, though. I was there a couple weeks ago and someone played a whole run of old soul 45s, or maybe CDs that sounded like 45s. Either way, it worked. If you’re doing a crawl, Franklin then Wyckoff then maybe Red Hook is a lot. Pick two.

#7

Just tried the Franklin Ave spot after work—went in around 7 and it was pretty empty, but the jukebox had actual CDs and the bartender was cool about it. Is that the one you meant, grand_st_g? I didn’t stay long because I was solo, but I’d go back with a friend. Thanks for the rec.