Late dinner after Lincoln Center: where do four people eat at 10 without a reservation?
#1

Got a 7:30 show at Lincoln Center on Friday, four adults, one vegetarian, and I did not plan dinner because I am an optimist. Looking for a sit-down place where we can walk in around 10 and actually eat—not just pick at a sad plate of fries. Doesn't need to be fancy. Just good, not a tourist trap, and not a second mortgage. Ideally within a 10–15 minute walk. Am I dreaming or does this exist?

#2

Not dreaming, but you gotta be honest about "kitchen open till 10" vs "we seat you at 10." Big difference. If you're flexible on the walk, the Vietnamese place on Amsterdam in the 70s is my move—pho, rice plates, veg options, and they've always got tables later than you'd think. Not a special-occasion spot, but solid. Call first. Friday at Lincoln Center is a different animal.

#3

Oh, if the vegetarian eats tofu and mushrooms, do NOT sleep on the Sichuan place on Amsterdam in the upper 70s! The dry-fried green beans are ridiculous—ask them to do it without pork if needed—and the mapo tofu is a whole thing. It's not quiet, it's not fancy, but it is exactly what you want after a show. Have you tried their cold noodles? Because that's the move while you wait for a table. Call ahead though, seriously!

#4

Staten_Steve is right about the distinction, and it's the one that sinks these plans. A lot of UWS places post "open until 11" but the kitchen stops taking orders at 10, and a 7:30 curtain at Lincoln Center means you're out around 10 anyway. I'd narrow it to three types: (1) the old-school Italian on Columbus in the 70s/80s—red sauce, chicken parm, a couple of vegetarian pastas, but call and ask whether they'll seat four at 10; (2) the mezze/Greek spot on Amsterdam, which is better for a mixed group because you can order small plates and nobody cares if the vegetarian just eats three kinds of eggplant; (3) the Sichuan option Tacodeldia mentioned, if everyone is okay with heat and a louder room. I'd avoid the places directly across from the plaza—they're fine, but you're paying for the location and the food is not the point. Also, Friday night during the season: make a reservation if you can, even a 9:45. "Walk-in" works better for two than four.

#5

I'd second the mezze idea over Italian for a group with one vegetarian. The Italian places around there are good but the veg options can be "penne with broccoli" and that's it. The Greek/mezze route lets you spread the risk. Also the French bistro on Columbus around 82nd sometimes seats people at the bar later—not ideal for four, but worth a call if you're stuck.

#6

Yeah, I wouldn't try to be cute on a Friday. The Sichuan place is a good call if the veg person is actually into tofu—some "vegetarian" friends I know would rather eat a plain pizza. If not, the diner on Broadway is fine but it's not a recommendation, it's a fallback. What about the Japanese place on Amsterdam in the low 80s? Small, but they might squeeze you in. I'd call all of them at like 6 and ask straight up.

#7

Good stuff. To be clear, the vegetarian is a real vegetarian—fish is not a vegetable in her book—but she's not scared of spice. Sounds like Amsterdam is the move. Tacodeldia, do you think the Sichuan place will take a walk-in four at 10, or am I setting myself up? I can call, I just don't want to be that guy holding a table while we're still at the show.

#8

Morningside_M, call them at 9:45, not 10:05! That's the sweet spot. And be honest—say four people, one vegetarian, probably there by 10:15. They'd rather know than have you roll in at 10:30 with everyone hungry and cranky. If they say no, the mezze place is the backup, and honestly the backup might be better for the vegetarian anyway. Have you tried the roasted eggplant there? Get two orders. And the bread. Always the bread.