Posts: 10
Joined: Sep 2026
I'm at 86th and Second, and every morning I watch the M15-SBS sail by while I'm trudging to the 6. I keep wondering if I'm being an idiot for not just staying above ground to Fulton. I know it has a dedicated lane most of the way, but lights, passengers, double-parked trucks... Anyone actually commute this regularly? I'm not looking for "I took it once on a Sunday and it was great." Real weekday around 8 a.m. comparison, door to door.
Posts: 116
Joined: Feb 2026
I did it for a month when the 6 was doing that signal work. Short answer: no. The bus is fine to maybe 34th, then it crawls. You're also rolling the dice on the dispatcher holding at 96th for no reason. I'd take the 4/5 from 86th if you're going to Fulton. The walk to Lex is annoying but at least it's predictable.
Posts: 25
Joined: Oct 2026
Woodhaven_W is right about the crawl below 34th. I'll add one narrow case: if you're going to Beekman or the hospitals, M15 is actually decent because you skip the transfer at Fulton. For actual Fulton, subway wins. The bus is also way less miserable in the rain, which counts for something.
Posts: 4
Joined: Sep 2026
Unpopular opinion but I think people overrate the 4/5 from 86th. By the time you walk to Lex, wait, and cram into a packed train, the M15 has often already passed 72nd. The problem isn't the bus itself, it's the variance. If you need a guaranteed arrival time, subway. If you just need to get downtown and can leave 10 minutes early, the bus is less stressful. I wouldn't call it faster, but "romanticizing" is harsh.