Posts: 14
Joined: Sep 2026
So my roommate's boyfriend has been at our place basically every night for like two months. He's not on the lease, doesn't pay anything, but he's using the shower, doing laundry, eating our food. We have a two-bedroom in the East Village, and the lease says only named tenants can occupy. My other roommate is chill, I'm not. Do we have to formally add him? Or can we just ask for a utility contribution? What's the line between 'guest' and 'tenant' in NYC? I don't want to get the landlord involved if we can avoid it, but I also don't want to be subsidizing some dude's life.
Posts: 40
Joined: Jun 2026
Yo, that's a classic. In my old place we had a 'guest' who was there so much the super thought he lived there. If he's getting mail there or has a key, he's basically a tenant. But if he's just staying over, it's a gray area. Your lease probably has a guest clause—like no more than X consecutive days. Check that first. Asking for utilities is the minimum. He's using hot water and electricity.
Posts: 19
Joined: Jun 2026
Agree with LowerEast_L on the guest clause. Also, if your roommate's name is the only one on the lease for that room, it's their problem to manage their guest. But you and the other roommate shouldn't eat the cost. I'd say: either he chips in a fixed amount monthly or he's not there more than 3 nights a week. Simple. If they push back, mention the lease. No need to narc to the landlord yet.
Posts: 6
Joined: Sep 2026
Not to be dramatic but this is how roommate horror stories start. I had a situation where the boyfriend basically moved in, and when we asked for money he got all offended. Then he started leaving his stuff everywhere. Set a boundary now. Also, if he's there when your roommate isn't, that's weird. Is he getting packages? That's a sign.
Posts: 14
Joined: Sep 2026
Yeah, he does get packages. And he has a key. My roommate gave him one 'for emergencies.' I feel like that pushes it past guest. I'm gonna check the lease tonight. The guest clause is probably like 14 days or something. But I don't want to be the bad guy. Maybe a house meeting?
Posts: 40
Joined: Jun 2026
House meeting for sure. But go in with numbers—like 'our electric bill went up X since he started staying over.' Don't make it emotional. Also, check if your lease says anything about unauthorized occupants; some landlords can hit you with fees or even eviction. Not trying to scare you but it's real. If he's getting mail there, that's a residency thing.
Posts: 19
Joined: Jun 2026
Real talk: if he has a key and gets mail, he's living there. Adding him to the lease might not even be possible if your landlord is strict. And if you do add him, your rent could go up or they could re-run credit. Do you actually want him on the lease? Because then he has rights. Maybe better to keep it informal but make him pay.
Posts: 6
Joined: Sep 2026
I'd avoid adding him to the lease if you can. That's a whole application process and fees. But you need a written agreement between the three of you—like a roommate agreement addendum. Say he contributes $X per month and if he's there more than 4 nights a week he pays more. Also, who's cleaning? Because I bet he's not cleaning.
Posts: 14
Joined: Sep 2026
Update: I checked the lease. It says 'no more than 7 consecutive days or 14 days in any 6-month period' for guests. He's way over. I'm not trying to get anyone evicted but I'm also not trying to lose my apartment. I'll talk to my roommate first, then maybe draft a simple agreement. Thanks for the reality check.
Posts: 40
Joined: Jun 2026
Good call. And if your roommate gets defensive, remind them that if the landlord finds out, you all could be on the hook. It's not just about money—it's about keeping the lease. Also, maybe suggest he contribute to groceries if he's eating your stuff. That's just rude.
Posts: 19
Joined: Jun 2026
Let us know how it goes. If they refuse to budge, you might have to loop in the landlord. But hopefully it doesn't get there. One more thing: if he's using your address for anything official, that's a bigger issue. Check the mail situation.
Posts: 6
Joined: Sep 2026
Also, if you do a written agreement, make it clear it's month-to-month and can be revoked. And keep a copy. People get weird when money is involved. Good luck—sounds like you're handling it right.